(262) 547-7965 Waukesha, WI

Google Reviews

Photo of Nicole Meifert

Nicole Meifert

I have been using Goodness Insurance for years. My mom and sister also use Goodness. They always find me the best deal. Every year they look to make sure that I am getting the cheapest deal for what my coverage needs are. This is a family owned and run business and I refer everyone I know there. They are all so pleasant, prompt in returning calls and willing to help whenever I call. I highly recommend them!
Photo of Brian Turley

Brian Turley

I have been with Goodness Insurance for over 23 years. Tom and the entire team have taken excellent care of ALL my insurance needs. For the very few claims I have needed to file they have taken care of everything. For the things that I have needed to do or papers I have needed sign there is always a follow up phone call and email to make sure I have it done. Often I need the reminders. If a change of policy is in order they call with suggestions and recommendations. They ALWAYS go above and beyond. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Photo of Renee Bremberger

Renee Bremberger

I have been a client of goodness INS for years and years! They do their very best to try and find the most reasonable rates and are ALWAYS available if there is ever a time that you need to speak with someone quickly! Great customer service! I would reach out to Goodness INS even if your not looking. It never hurts to have someone else check into rates to see if they can help save you money $
Keep up the excellent work! I have always had my vehicles and boat coverage through them. Thanks for the great customer service :)
Photo of Shelley Gallamore

Shelley Gallamore

I highly recommend the Goodness Insurance team - Marissa and Tom have been incredibly helpful to us throughout the process of setting up a small business and all the necessary insurance! They answer questions quickly, talk through our needs and work hard to make sure we are protected!
Photo of Krystal P.

Krystal P.

I got my first auto insurance from Goodness as a college student who had other things to worry about than what kind of coverage I would need for a 16 year old car. Marissa and Bud both helped navigate these foreign waters, making sense of grown-up sounding words like "deductible" and what kind of coverage was best suited to my needs, even if it didn't necessarily help line their pockets. Fast forward a couple of years when I got a newer vehicle and they looked over my driving history, the rate I was paying at the time, and updated my coverage. When they saw I could get a better rate through another insurance provider, Marissa explained the differences between each company, how often/quickly they pay out if something were to happen, and other customer reviews of each business.

The entire time I've been a customer of theirs, the good people at Goodness Insurance have educated me and empowered me to make my own, informed decisions without strong arming me one or another, and without making me pay outrageous premiums for coverage I didn't need, even when I was an ignorant college student they could have easily taken advantage of.

Welcome to Goodness Insurance

Happy Family

We are an Independent Insurance Agency, which means we have several carriers available to quote with:. online quick quotes

We service the Waukesha, Pewaukee, Delafield, Brookfield, WI.  areas, and throughout the state of WI. At Goodness Insurance each one of our clients are given a dedicated team of licensed insurance agents that work together to proficiently address all your concerns.

We offer all types of Personal Insurance coverages to our clients in WI, including AutoHomeMotorcycleBoat & WatercraftFlood Insurance, and Life insurance.

Give one of our agents a call to save money on your business insurance. Some of our Commercial insurance coverages include Business Owners Packages (BOP), General Liability, Commercial Auto, Commercial Real Estate, and Contractors insurance

Let us help you cut your insurance cost! Just give us a quick call today at 262-547-7965 or submit one of our quick online quote forms - with the help of our dedicated business partners; we conveniently offer an entire solution for all your insurance and business needs.

Why Our Agency is the Ideal Choice

Friendly Customer Service

Goodness Insurance is renowned for treating clients like family with our genuinely friendly customer service. Our team excels in offering personalized, clear guidance, making insurance approachable. We prioritize understanding and addressing client needs with warmth and patience. 

Experience and Knowledge

The Goodness Insurance in Waukesha, Pewaukee, Delafield, Brookfield, WI.  transforms your insurance journey with unmatched expertise and experience. Our dedicated team simplifies complex choices, ensuring personalized coverage that fits your unique needs, with the assurance of our long-standing industry knowledge and commitment to excellence. 

Securing the Best Rates

At Goodness Insurance, we tirelessly shop for the most competitive insurance rates, ensuring you get the best value without compromising on coverage. Our relentless pursuit is to find optimal, customized solutions that align with your budget and needs, while delivering peace of mind.

American Modern
Badger Mutual
Germantown Mutual
State Auto
West Bend